People hear the word biochar and picture a black powder that cleans dirty ground. On mined land it can help a plant cover take hold, and it can hold some metals in place. It does not take those metals away. On some sites it can even make one of them, arsenic, easier to move.
At GoSí BioTech we plan to make biochar from part of a grass harvest and put it back on the same mined ground. How that loop fits with the grass and BioCNG is in Mine land rehabilitation with C4 grasses, biochar and BioCNG. What a plant cover can and cannot do is in What phytoremediation can, and cannot, do on mined land. Our 10-hectare pilot has not started. We have no field results of our own to report.
What is biochar?
It is a carbon-rich solid made by heating plant material with very little oxygen. That process is called pyrolysis. The International Biochar Initiative describes it as a solid produced by the thermal decomposition of biomass under a limited supply of oxygen. A standard text by Lehmann and Joseph uses the same idea: biomass heated in a closed container with little or no available air.
The result is porous, and it has a large surface. That surface is why people turn to it on contaminated soil. It is an amendment, not a plant, and not a wash of the soil.
What it can do on mined soil
Mine wastes are often acidic, low in organic matter, poor at holding water, and rich in metals. A review of biochar on mine tailings describes those limits as the reason plants struggle to establish. Biochar can improve that surface. Two reviews of contaminated soils describe a liming effect on acid ground, and a gain in water holding, when the char is alkaline. That can give plants a better chance to root.
The same surface can bind some metals. Metals that sit in soil water with a positive charge, such as cadmium, lead, zinc and copper, often become less mobile when biochar is mixed into a contaminated soil. The reviews describe binding on the char, and a rise in pH that can move those metals into less available forms. That is immobilization. The metals stay in the ground.
A living cover is still the thing that stops dust and runoff. I wrote about that in the phytoremediation article. Biochar is one more amendment, not a substitute for the cover.
Why the effect is not the same on every metal
Arsenic does not behave like lead or cadmium. In soil water it is usually present in a form that carries a negative charge. Its mobility often rises as pH rises. That is the opposite of the usual pattern for those other metals.
A 2011 review in Environmental Pollution is plain about the risk: the liming effect of biochar, or the release of soluble carbon, may increase arsenic mobility. A later review of soil amendments reaches the same caution: some biochars have increased the mobility of arsenic, and of antimony, through a higher pH and through competition on the soil surface. I will not treat biochar as a blanket fix for every metal on a tailings pond.
The picture is also not the same in every trial. In a Thai study on gold-mine tailings, a Napier variety grown with acacia-wood biochar or cow manure took up far less arsenic and manganese than plants grown without those amendments. That study is one case, on one tailings material, with one char. It does not cancel the reviews. It is a reason to test the mix on the site, including the metals that may move the other way.
Why the feedstock and the mix matter
Not every biochar is the same. The International Biochar Initiative and the research reviews both say the feedstock, and the way the char is made, including the temperature, shape what it will do in soil. A wood char and a manure char will not behave the same way. A char made at a low temperature will not have the same surface as one made at a high temperature. Many biochars can raise pH on acid soils. Not all of them are alkaline.
On degraded ground, biochar used alone can also be a poor food for plants. The 2011 review notes that a low store of nutrients, plus a tight hold on the nutrients that are there, can restrict revegetation when biochar is the only amendment. The authors point to a mix with compost or manure as the more useful way to use biochar on soils that need a plant cover to hold. That matches the practical advice on our rehabilitation article.
I would not put a char on a tailings pond and walk away. The mix has to be chosen for the metals that are there, and then checked in the soil water and in the plants, not only in a laboratory binding test.
What we will test, and what we have not tested yet
The plan is to make biochar from part of the Pakchong 1 harvest and return it to the same 10-hectare site, with digestate. The pilot has not started. There are no GoSí measurements of pH, metals, plant uptake or cover to report. It is planned to run for 18 months, with candidate regions in Ghana, Australia, South Africa and Spain. Details of that loop are in the rehabilitation article. More on the candidate grass and the pilot is on the GoSí BioTech homepage.
During the pilot we will test metal levels in soil, plants, biochar and digestate. That work has to include arsenic where it is present, not only the metals that biochar is expected to bind. Until those data exist, I will not preview a result.
If you hold a closed or closing site, or if you are responsible for abandoned mine land, you are welcome to contact us. Investors can also start on the investors page.
FAQ
Does biochar remove heavy metals from mined soil?
No. It can bind some metals and reduce the share that is readily mobile. The metals stay in the ground. That is immobilization, not a clean-up.
Can biochar make arsenic more mobile?
Yes, it can. Reviews warn that a rise in pH, or in soluble carbon, may increase arsenic mobility. Some tailings trials have still shown lower uptake into plants. The only honest step is to test the char on the site.
Should biochar be used on its own on tailings?
Often no. On poor ground it is usually more useful mixed with compost or manure, and it is not a substitute for a living cover.
Has GoSí tested biochar on a mine?
No. The 10-hectare pilot has not started. We have no field results of our own.
More insights
What phytoremediation can, and cannot, do on mined land
On mined land, phytoremediation usually means covering the ground so dust and water do not carry the metals. It does not take the metals away.
What phytoremediation can, and cannot, do on mined landMine land rehabilitation with C4 grasses, biochar and BioCNG
How a fast-growing grass, biochar and a biogas digester can cover bare mine ground and limit erosion and dust (phytostabilisation).
Mine land rehabilitation with C4 grasses, biochar and BioCNG