People hear the word phytoremediation and picture plants pulling metals out of an old mine. That is one use of the word. On most mined land, it is not the job that plants can actually do.

The metals stay in the ground. The practical work is to stop them moving, in dust and in runoff, by getting a living cover to hold.

At GoSí BioTech we work on that kind of cover, with C4 grasses, and with biochar and digestate returned to the soil. How a grass harvest, biochar and BioCNG fit together is in Mine land rehabilitation with C4 grasses, biochar and BioCNG. Our 10-hectare pilot has not started. We have no field results of our own to report.

What does phytoremediation mean?

It is a broad term. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency describes it as the use of plants to remediate selected contaminants in soil, sludge, sediment or water. That work can be a clean-up, or it can be containment. The two are not the same.

Phytoextraction is a removal process. Plants take metals into the stems and leaves, and the harvest is taken away. It only works if enough metal moves into the shoots, and if that harvest can be handled safely.

Phytostabilization is a containment process. The plants and the soil around their roots hold the metals in place. The cover can also limit erosion, dust and leachate. The metals are not removed. Because the contaminants remain, the cover has to be kept, or shown to keep itself, so they are not released again. A 2003 review of mine-soil restoration reaches the same split. For bare tailings, the first job is almost always that stable cover, not a harvest of metal-rich shoots.

Why mined land is a hard case

Mine wastes are not ordinary soil. They are often low in organic matter and nutrients, poor in structure, and rich in metals. Some are acidic. Wind and rain can move the fine material, and with it the metals, into air, streams and neighbouring land. If nothing grows, the surface stays a source of dust and runoff.

The problem is not only a wet-climate one. A review in Environmental Health Perspectives notes unreclaimed tailings in arid and semiarid regions across northern Mexico and the western United States, the Pacific coast of South America, southwestern Spain, South Africa and Australia. Those dry sites are especially open to windblow and water erosion.

Why a cover is usually the practical choice

I would not sell phytoremediation of a tailings pond as a way to strip the metals out. On most sites the useful work is to keep the waste where it is.

The plants that fit this job tolerate metals and keep them in the roots, or bound in the soil around the roots, rather than sending them up into the shoots. A living cover is also a physical cap. A review of metalliferous mine wastes treats vegetation as the best long-term way to stop contaminated particles blowing away and to intercept rainfall. This is management, not a clean bill of health. If the cover dies back, or the site is disturbed, the metals can move again. Long-term upkeep, or a cover that can sustain itself, is part of the method.

Why the plants usually need help

A seed thrown on raw tailings often fails. Reviews of mine-soil restoration say amendments should be added to help stabilize the spoil and give plants a chance to root. Compost, manure and, where the chemistry requires it, a lime-type material are the usual tools. They can raise pH, add organic matter and reduce the share of metal that is readily available to move.

Biochar is one more amendment, not a substitute for the cover. Two reviews describe how its surface can bind metals in contaminated soil, and how it can improve poor tailings enough for plants to establish. The effect depends on the soil and the metal, so it has to be tested for the site. On degraded ground, biochar is often more useful mixed with compost or manure than used alone.

This is not only a laboratory idea. In the Cartagena-La Unión mining district in southeast Spain, field trials have used aided phytostabilization: native plants plus organic amendments and a carbonate material. After several years, soil conditions improved and the bioavailable share of metals fell. Cover was uneven in the later, larger trial, in part because of micro-topography and runoff from unrestored ground. The same lesson applies in similar dry districts in Mexico, Chile and Peru: choose plants that can live there, amend the surface, and design the ground so rain does not undo the work.

Where grasses fit, and what the studies actually show

Grasses are often used because they can close a surface quickly and put a dense root mat into the top of the waste. That is a revegetation and stabilization role. It is not proof that a grass takes up or tolerates every metal on every site.

Our current candidate is Pakchong 1, a hybrid of Napier grass and pearl millet. It is a C4 perennial. The published work I rely on here is on Napier grasses, not a field trial of Pakchong 1 on mine soil. More on why we chose this grass is on the GoSí BioTech homepage.

In a six-month pot trial in Thailand, cadmium in Napier grass stayed higher in the roots than in the shoots, and the translocation factor was very low. The authors treated Napier grass as a candidate for cadmium phytostabilization, not as a plant for stripping cadmium out of the soil. In a second Thai study, a Napier variety grown on gold-mine tailings with cow manure or acacia-wood biochar took up far less arsenic and manganese than plants grown without those amendments.

I will not treat Pakchong 1 as if it had already been proven on a mine. Reviews of tailings work often prefer native plants for a long-lived cover. That remains a fair test for any candidate, including ours. We will have to show, on a real site, that the grass establishes, that the cover holds, and that metals stay out of the harvest stream we intend to use.

What we will test, and what we have not tested yet

The plan is a 10-hectare Phase 0 pilot on abandoned mined land. It has not started. There are no GoSí measurements of cover, erosion, metals or biogas to report. It is planned to run for 18 months, in more than one climate. The candidate regions are Tarkwa in Ghana, the Pilbara in Australia, the Witwatersrand in South Africa, and Spain. Details of the grass, biochar and biogas loop are in the rehabilitation article. Metal levels in soil, plants, biochar and digestate will be tested during the pilot. Until those data exist, I will not preview a result.

If you hold a closed or closing site, or if you are responsible for abandoned mine land, you are welcome to contact us. Investors can also start on the investors page.

FAQ

Does phytoremediation remove heavy metals from mined land?

Not in the form most often used on tailings. Phytostabilization holds the metals in place under a plant cover. It does not take them away. Phytoextraction can remove some metal in a harvest, but only if the plants accumulate enough of it in the shoots and the harvest is taken off the site.

What is the difference between phytostabilization and phytoextraction?

Phytostabilization is containment: roots and a living cover keep metals from moving in dust and water. Phytoextraction is removal: metals are taken into the shoots and carried off when the plants are harvested.

Can Napier grass or Pakchong 1 clean mine soil?

No. In the Napier studies cited here, cadmium stayed mostly in the roots, and amendments reduced arsenic and manganese uptake on gold-mine tailings. That is a case for careful phytostabilization tests, not for a clean-up claim. Pakchong 1 has not yet been tested by GoSí on a mine. The pilot has not started.

Why add compost or biochar?

Raw mine waste is often too poor for plants to establish. Organic amendments can improve the surface and, in many cases, reduce the share of metal that is readily mobile. Biochar can help bind some metals, often more usefully when mixed with compost or manure. The mix still has to be tested for the site.

More insights

Partner / Invest